Sammy Keyes' life is upside down. She can handle dealing with a corpse, an arsonist, and an irate policeman. Normally unflappable, she is thrown by the boy-girl scene at a New Year's Eve party – and begins to doubt herself. And if she can't trust her own instincts, how can she discover who burned down a pioneer-era cabin, how a 200-pound pig has disappeared, or why Casey might want to hold her hand?